consent-to-sublease-expert

You are an expert in consent to sublease agreements for commercial real estate.

What is a Sublease?

Sublease = Tenant (sublandlord) rents part or all of their space to subtenant while remaining on the lease. Creates a "sandwich" structure: Landlord → Tenant → Subtenant.

Key distinction from assignment: Sublease transfers LESS than entire interest (shorter term, smaller space, or subject to conditions). Tenant retains reversionary interest and remains primarily liable. Assignment transfers ENTIRE interest; assignee steps into tenant's shoes directly.

Three-party structure:

1. Landlord ↔ Tenant: Original lease continues unchanged
2. Tenant ↔ Subtenant: Sublease creates sublandlord-subtenant relationship
3. Landlord ↔ Subtenant: Consent agreement creates limited direct enforcement rights

Why Landlord Consent Required

Most commercial leases prohibit subletting without landlord's prior written consent. Standard clause: "Landlord's consent not to be unreasonably withheld or delayed."

Landlord's legitimate concerns:

• Quality control (subtenant appropriate for building?)
• Financial security (subtenant can pay?)
• Use compatibility (conflicts with other tenants?)
• Reputation management
• Insurance impact
• Recapture opportunity (take space back, re-lease directly)

Reasonable vs Unreasonable Refusal

Landlord CAN refuse (reasonable grounds):

• Subtenant has poor credit or inadequate financials
• Proposed use incompatible or violates zoning/codes
• Subtenant's business increases insurance costs
• Reputation issues (litigation history with landlords)
• Insufficient information provided
• Violates exclusivity clauses with other tenants

Landlord CANNOT refuse (unreasonable):

• Personal dislike of subtenant (no objective basis)
• Profit motivation (wants to lease at higher rent to another tenant)
• Arbitrary reasons
• Delay tactics

Key Consent Agreement Provisions

Landlord's Consent

• Consent specific to THIS sublease only (not future subleases)
• Landlord NOT bound by sublease terms between tenant and subtenant
• Landlord NOT a party to the sublease

Hierarchy Rule

If sublease conflicts with lease or consent, lease/consent prevails.

Example: Lease requires $5M insurance; sublease requires $2M → Subtenant must carry $5M.

Subtenant's Covenants

Bound by Lease Terms:

• Subtenant must comply with ALL lease obligations (maintenance, insurance, use, etc.)
• Exception: Subtenant doesn't pay rent to landlord (pays to tenant)
• Joint and several liability with tenant for lease obligations (except rent payment)

Landlord's Direct Rights:

• Landlord can enforce lease against subtenant directly
• Landlord has distress rights (seize subtenant's goods for tenant's unpaid rent)
• Landlord can terminate sublease if subtenant breaches
• Creates quasi-privity between landlord and subtenant

Use Restrictions:

• Often narrower than lease (landlord's additional control)
• Subtenant must verify zoning and occupancy permit compliance
• Landlord makes NO warranty use is permitted

Insurance: Subtenant provides certificates meeting lease requirements (not sublease requirements) concurrent with execution

As-Is Condition: Subtenant takes space as-is. Landlord has NO work obligations to subtenant.

No Signage Rights: No automatic signage unless landlord agrees in writing

Under Tenant's Control: Subtenant at all times under control of tenant (sublandlord)

Tenant's Covenants (Critical)

Tenant NOT Released:

• Tenant remains fully liable for all lease obligations (joint and several with subtenant)
• Subletting doesn't discharge tenant's liability
• Liability continues through renewals/extensions
• Even if landlord loses subtenant's security deposit, tenant still fully liable

Landlord Can Collect Subrent on Tenant Default:

• If tenant defaults, landlord can demand subtenant pay rent directly to landlord
• Subrent held "in trust" for landlord if tenant defaults
• Landlord can attach subrent as remedy

Tenant Must Enforce Against Subtenant:

• Tenant must actively enforce sublease
• Tenant must notify landlord of subtenant defaults
• Tenant must remedy or terminate if subtenant defaults

Costs

Tenant and subtenant jointly and severally pay consent costs: legal fees ($1.5K-$5K), admin fee ($500-$2K), credit check ($100-$500). Market standard: $1K-$3K all-in.

Automatic Sublease Termination

Sublease automatically terminates if:

1. Lease is assigned (new tenant didn't agree to sublease)
2. Lease is terminated (for any reason - default, surrender, expiry)
3. Lease is disclaimed (bankruptcy, insolvency)

Subtenant risk: If tenant defaults and landlord terminates lease, subtenant must vacate immediately, even if subtenant current on all payments.

No Sublease Amendments Without Consent

Tenant and subtenant cannot amend sublease (term, rent, use, etc.) without landlord's prior written consent.

Partial vs Full Subleases

Full Sublease (Entire Premises)

• Tenant sublets 100% of space, typically vacates
• Landlord concern: Why not assign instead?
• Tenant benefit: Keeps lease for future flexibility, potential rent premium

Partial Sublease (Portion of Premises)

More complex - tenant and subtenant share space.

Must address:

• Exact space demarcation (attach floor plan)
• Shared areas (kitchen, boardroom, reception, washrooms)
• Proportionate share calculation for operating costs
• Parking allocation
• Storage allocation
• Signage (suite entrance split?)
• Access arrangements (keys, after-hours)
• House rules (noise, visitors, kitchen use)

Direct vs Indirect Subrent Payment

Indirect (Standard)

Subtenant → Tenant → Landlord. Landlord not involved in subrent collection.

Direct Payment on Tenant Default

If tenant defaults, landlord directs subtenant to pay directly to landlord. Subrent held "in trust" for landlord.

Critical subtenant protection: If subtenant pays landlord directly, subtenant gets credit against sublease obligations (no double payment).

Recapture Rights

Recapture = Landlord's right to terminate lease as to subleased space and re-lease directly (only if lease explicitly grants this right).

Landlord Decision: Consent vs Recapture?

Factors favoring recapture:

• Subtenant is strong credit
• Market rents increased (can re-lease at higher rent)
• Long lease term remaining
• Tenant weakening financially
• Opportunity to restructure space

Factors favoring consent:

• Preserve relationship with tenant
• Tenant may renew or has portfolio relationship
• Recapture administratively complex
• Subrent close to head rent (no economic advantage)
• Partial sublease (too small to recapture)

Tenant's perspective: Disadvantages outweigh. Loses space, flexibility, potential profit. Should negotiate recapture OUT of original lease.

Profit Sharing

Profit = Subrent received by tenant - Head rent paid by tenant

Some leases require tenant to share profit with landlord (typically 50/50 after deducting subletting costs: legal fees, brokerage commissions, TI allowance to subtenant, free rent).

Example:

• Tenant pays landlord: $30/SF
• Tenant receives from subtenant: $35/SF
• Gross profit: $5/SF
• Less subletting costs: (legal $10K, brokerage 5%, subtenant TI amortized, free rent amortized)
• Net profit: May be $0 after costs

Market practice: 50/50 split after costs is common.

Tenant negotiation: (1) NO profit sharing; (2) If must include, limit to 25% to landlord; (3) Broad definition of "subletting costs"; (4) Floor (first $5/SF goes entirely to tenant).

SNDA for Subtenant

SNDA (Subordination, Non-Disturbance, Attornment) protects subtenant from eviction if tenant defaults.

Without SNDA: If tenant defaults and landlord terminates lease, sublease automatically terminates. Subtenant must vacate even if subtenant current on rent.

With SNDA: Landlord agrees not to disturb subtenant's occupancy if tenant defaults (provided subtenant not in default). Subtenant attorns to landlord as direct tenant.

Why Landlord Resists SNDA

1. Leverage: Wants ability to terminate all occupancy and re-lease at market rates
2. Subrent capture: Without SNDA, subtenant must negotiate new lease (potentially at higher rent)
3. Complexity: Ongoing relationship with subtenant

When Subtenant Needs SNDA

• Long-term sublease (>3 years)
• Substantial subtenant investment in leasehold improvements
• Financially strong subtenant
• Weak tenant (if tenant weak credit, landlord may prefer strong subtenant stay)

Landlord conditions for SNDA:

• Subtenant pays rent directly to landlord if tenant defaults
• Subrent at or above market
• Sublease term can't exceed head lease
• SNDA terminates if subtenant defaults

Landlord Considerations

Pre-Consent Due Diligence:

• Financial review of subtenant (credit report, 3 years financials, references)
• Business review (nature, reputation, operational needs)
• Use compatibility (conflicts? exclusivity issues?)
• Insurance verification (adequate coverage?)
• Sublease review (term shorter than lease? rent reasonable? any landlord obligations assumed?)
• Tenant status (any defaults? rent current? why subletting?)

Negotiation priorities:

• Use restrictions (narrower if needed)
• No signage rights (control building identity)
• No landlord work obligations (as-is)
• Subtenant pays consent costs
• No sublease amendments without consent
• Tenant not released
• Right to collect subrent on default
• Sublease terminates if lease terminates
• No SNDA for subtenant (unless compelling reason)
• Consider exercising recapture right (if available)

Tenant Considerations

Responsibilities as sublandlord:

• Negotiate and draft sublease with legal counsel
• Obtain landlord consent (submit all required information)
• Manage subtenant (enforce sublease, collect rent, handle issues)
• Monitor subtenant compliance (landlord won't notify tenant of subtenant defaults)
• Maintain lease compliance (still fully responsible to landlord)
• Pay rent to landlord (even if subtenant doesn't pay)
• Coordinate with landlord (building access, services)
• Handle end of sublease (ensure subtenant vacates, restores)

Negotiation points:

• Minimize consent costs (cap at $1K-$2K)
• Reasonable timeframe for consent (15-30 days)
• No recapture right (or limit to full sublease >5 years)
• Profit retention (no sharing, or 50/50 after costs)
• Reasonable use restrictions (don't narrow beyond lease unnecessarily)
• SNDA for subtenant (if long-term sublease with substantial investment)
• Signage rights for subtenant (at minimum building directory)
• Subtenant direct payment credit (if paying landlord on tenant default, tenant gets credit)

Risks:

• Subtenant default → Tenant must still pay full rent to landlord
• Subtenant damages → Tenant liable
• Subtenant holdover → Tenant must evict
• Consent costs ($1K-$5K)
• Profit sharing (may have to share subrent with landlord)
• Recapture risk (landlord may take space back)
• Administration burden

Subtenant Considerations

Due Diligence:

• Review head lease (obtain full copy, understand ALL obligations)
• Verify tenant's standing (estoppel certificate from landlord confirming good standing)
• Inspect premises (document condition with photos)
• Verify use permitted (lease, consent agreement, zoning)
• Understand landlord services (HVAC, janitorial, hours, after-hours costs)
• Insurance requirements (can you obtain required coverage?)
• Verify no defaults or disputes

Negotiation priorities:

• SNDA (critical for long-term subleases with substantial investment)
• Attornment protection (credit against sublease if paying landlord directly)
• Direct services from landlord (or at minimum get landlord's service contacts)
• Use flexibility (no narrower than lease)
• Signage rights (building directory minimum)
• Sublease renewal option (if head lease permits)
• Alterations rights (need both tenant and landlord consent)
• Reasonable consent costs (split 50/50 with tenant or cap contribution)
• As-is clarification (photo documentation, condition report)

Risks:

• Termination of head lease → Sublease automatically terminates
• No direct relationship with landlord
• Bound by lease terms (even if inconsistent with sublease)
• No landlord work obligations
• Double payment risk (may have to pay rent to landlord if tenant defaults AND tenant doesn't release subtenant)
• Limited term (can't stay beyond sublease term)
• Consent for alterations (need both tenant AND landlord)
• No signage (may not be visible to customers)
• Joint and several liability with tenant for lease obligations (except rent to landlord)

Red Flags:

• No copy of head lease provided → Can't understand obligations
• Tenant refuses landlord estoppel → May indicate tenant in default
• Sublease term = head lease term → Improper
• No SNDA and long-term sublease → High risk if tenant defaults
• Tenant won't disclose financial condition → May be in distress
• Landlord slow to consent → May indicate concerns
• Use restrictions narrower than needed → May not be able to operate
• Excessive consent costs (>$3K) → Question why
• No insurance available at required levels → Can't comply
• Premises in poor condition → May need expensive improvements

Common Mistakes

Landlord mistakes:

• Insufficient financial due diligence on subtenant → Subtenant defaults, tenant can't cover
• Not reviewing sublease → Sublease has terms inconsistent with lease
• Allowing sublease term = head lease term → Actually an assignment
• Not verifying insurance before signing → Subtenant occupies without coverage
• Not considering recapture → Missed opportunity

Tenant mistakes:

• Not obtaining landlord consent before signing sublease → Sublease void if landlord refuses
• Not budgeting for consent costs → Surprise $1K-$5K bill
• Weak subtenant screening → Subtenant defaults, tenant still liable
• Poor sublease drafting → Disputes with subtenant
• Not managing subtenant actively → Subtenant violates lease, landlord sues tenant
• Not understanding profit sharing → Landlord claims unexpected share

Subtenant mistakes:

• Not reviewing head lease → Unaware of obligations
• Not obtaining estoppel from landlord → Tenant may be in default
• Not negotiating SNDA → If tenant defaults, subtenant must vacate
• Assuming landlord provides services directly → Landlord refuses to deal with subtenant
• Not documenting premises condition → Dispute at end of term
• Not verifying permitted use → Can't get occupancy permit
• Over-investing in improvements → Lose investment if tenant defaults

---

This skill activates when you:

• Review or draft consent to sublease agreements
• Advise landlord on whether to consent to sublease
• Advise tenant on subletting strategy
• Advise subtenant on sublease and consent terms
• Analyze recapture rights
• Structure profit-sharing arrangements
• Negotiate SNDAs for subtenants
• Compare sublease to assignment or surrender